“Twilight: New Moon & “Call Of Duty”: Manifestations Of The Four Sirens & Four Horsemen Theories
The past week saw two very interesting events that should give perceptive curious types like myself great cause for concern: the global release of the Twilight sequel New Moon, raked in some $170M over the first weekend of said release, and was heralded as a kind of triumph for “Chick Lit” movies finally able to rival a Dark Knight or Star Wars premiere in terms of box office ticket sales, with pictures of “tween” girls and middleaged Moms camping out in long lines in front of theaters for as a full week to gain entry to the smash hit novel adaptation, the brainchild of a devout Mormon Mom and housewife.
While it is no doubt a milestone achievement from a financial standpoint, what didn’t seem to garner as much press, but was even MORE compelling on the same front, was the recent release of the intense video game Call Of Duty. Within roughly the same amount of time that the New Moon premiere ran-roughly 72 hours or so-COD made TWICE as much money in revenues as NW. The core audience for video games, of course, is Male.
While there have been a number of “takes” on what all this means in the blogosphere, from Susan Walsh of Hooking Up Smart, to Chuck Ross of Gucci Little Piggy and Whiskey of Whiskey’s Place, and all of them have been quite informative-personally, I find all of their pieces lacking in terms of “connecting the dots”-WHY do so many Women, moms and daughters like, so strongly identify with the Twlight series? WHY are so many grownassed MEN spend as much as $60US for a video game? What does all this say to us, on the psycho/social/sexual front?
That, is what this essay, aims to address.
OK, so let’s begin, and, as always, “Ladies First”…
It should go without saying, that the current Twilight craze is nothing new insofar as “Chick Lit” is concerned; a century ago, Barbara Cartland was cranking out steamy romance novels of the time, although she never could have imagined the sheer commercial success things like Twlight and what some call “Amish Porn” gets in our time (the latter phrase referring to a series of romance novels set in Pennsylvania Dutch Country). Romance novels, Soap Operas and the like, have been a part of the Human social landscape for at least the last century, if not longer.
But what IS markedly different now, is the unparalleled reach of this genre, due in large part to the multi-media age in which we live, but another major factor, is due to what blogger Roissy calls “The Four Sirens”. According to his theory, several major, and artificial, changes to the way Men and Women relate in sociosexual terms, have come down the pike over the past four decades in particular. They are:
1. Access to cheap, safe, and highly effective contraception, such as The Pill and Abortion
2. Urban anonymity (very important, since Females are much more sensitive to what others, particularly those they know well, such as close family members or friends, thinks of what they’re doing)
3. Access to Education and Money (two strong “liberating” factors for any human being, and can and will alter the “bargaining” that must be part of any mating dance)
4. And finally, massive support from the State, from No-Fault Divorce, to Affirmative Action (Title IX would be included here), to Sexual Harassment laws and other “interventions” in the workplace, to Welfare, and more-all basically and again, greatly altering the “terms of negotiation” between Men and Women along sociosexual lines.
Roissy asserts that these “Sirens” frees up Women like never before in Human History, to truly explore-*and act on*-their true erotic desires, with little to fear from realworld consequence. After much thought on the matter, I am inclined to agree with his analysis, and would like to further contend that the Twilight franchise, is a manifestation, at least in part, of the Four Sirens Theory.
In what way, you might ask? Simple-a century ago, literacy rates, particularly for Women, were drastically lower in America than they are today, meaning that it was a smaller pool of Women Cartland and others could market their wares to in the first place because Women by and large couldn’t read. But another reason why Twilight and related “Chick Porn” works have done so well is because Women of virtually ALL ages, now have more disposable-and independent-income than ever in recorded history. And again, keep in mind, while a Woman circa 1900 might have to hide her latest Cartland novel, today, it is seen as a kind of badge of honor to be a fan of the Twilight series, and so on.
In fact, to go just one step further, back in the day all a Woman *could do* was kind of “grin and bear it” if her husband was in some way lacking in terms of wooing her into romantic ecstasy, sneaking away to read a chapter or two of Cartland’s book here and there; today, Women openly complain of the Men in their life no measuring up to the Edward Cullens of the world. Now, mind you-I’m not arguing here whether all of this is “right or wrong”; rather, I am merely noting and pointing out, to you the dear reader, how things were and how they came to be, in our time, the grand sweep of change along the FST that has already been mentioned.
But that’s only one part of the equation; without a doubt, the Four Sirens has irrevocably changed all our lives, Women and Men both, some would say for the better, others would vociferously argue for the worse. But whatever side you come down on, I think we can all agree, that it is highly unlikely that we’re “going back”-no Woman worth the name would want a rollback on ANY of the Four Sirens-and, quiet as its kept, quite a few Men would feel some kind of way about that prospect, too.
So, we’re all stuck with it, LOL. And we’ll simply have to learn to manage and cope with the “fallout”-the unintended consequences that always follows any massive, sweeping social change.
A big part of that “fallout” is laidout by Game theorist and Futurist blogger known as The Fifth Horsemen, who has come up with what he calls the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse-a rather ominous sounding theory to be sure, but one that should be carefully considered as we watch the last week’s events unfold. TFH outlines his “Four Horsemen Theory” as a much needed “corrective” to the current sociosexual marketplace, along these lines:
1. Game (meaning, that even if only a relative few Men actually learn and wield its teachings, that it will be enough to “alter” the current market)
2. Sex-Tech (meaning, the wide availability of alternative sexually-oriented technologies-like 3D and Virtual Reality consoles and the like, along with “Sexbots”, will not only cause potentially millions of Men to “dropout” of the marketplace altogether, but also has the potential to “alter” said marketplace even more and in ways yet anticipated)
3. Expatriation (meaning, those Men with the means and will to do so, leave the USA to set up shop elsewhere in more “Man friendly” environments; with airfare getting ever cheaper, and with living standards rising throughout the world, even a common laborer can easily move to say, a South American or even EU-based country with relative ease)
4. And finally, Islam. TFH argues that, among the World’s Great Religions, Islam is the only one at present, that is “Male friendly”, and will become seen by Men, even those in the West, as a viable alternative to a Feminist-inspired legal, political and social system run amok. He cites the recent installation of Sharia-based civil law courts in the UK, and so on, as evidence of the strong cultural hold that Islam offers disaffected Males. Given the events of the past decade on the world stage, it is hard to argue Islam’s ability to speak unapologetically to Men in ways that neither Christianity or Judaism does.
The Fifth Horseman concludes his analysis by suggesting that the time when we can expect a fullout manifestation of his Four Horseman Theory will be the year 2020, when Feminist-inspired legal and political moves will have gone a bridge too far in their scope and reach, and when technology will have advanced enough to be highly effective and available for the average Man; this, according to TFH, will be the time of a “backlash” or “pushback” by Western Men enmasse.
After giving his words a great deal of thought, I must say that TFH has a good deal of powerful points, and would like to also suggest that what we saw over the past week, with the unprecedented success of the video game Call Of Duty is only a foreshadowing of what is surely to come-millions of grown Men basically “dropping out” of society and in relation to the Twilight phenomenon, “not showing up” to romance the ladies. For many of these Men, as Whiskey rightly points out, there’s little reason for them to bother “showing up”-much of the entertainment landscape doesn’t cater to their needs or interests, and the realworld, with its attendant maze of confusing and diminishing-returns ways of being, offers nothing a heck of a lot of Males would want to be bothered with. Here, a fundamental flaw of Feminist thinking exposes itself: one, did they honestly think that an opposite and equal reaction to their initiatives wouldn’t happen? And two, did they honestly think Men enmasse would simply “go along to get along”, when the easiest thing for ANY Man to do, is simply “drop out”? Even Mystery says as much in his book the Mystery Method, that the easiest thing a Man can do to get out of the reproductive rat race, is to merely sit down. If Call Of Duty is any indication, put together with Twilight, guys are doing just that. And if it’s like this now, w/a mainly violent war-based video game, imagine what it will be like a decade from now with VR and 3D, fully interactive Porn right from your Playstation or Wii.
Whew…
I believe it was Karl Marx who said that the great strength of Capitalism is its ability to quickly innovate with cutting edge technologies; but that its greatest weakness was in not keeping the Human Being at the center of all the great things said technology represents. Put another way, simply put, we Human Beings are “evolved enough” to deal with the Four Sirens, and the soon to come Four Horsemen in well-adjusted ways. The “adaptations” always lag behind the emergence of the technologies, and here, wrt Twilight and COD, we’re simply going to have to assume “Damage Control Mode” until we’ve figured all this out.
That means, a continued bifurcated society along gender lines, and cutting across all racial, ethnic and class lines, too. It means the death of “courting” and dating, and by extension, romance and seduction. It means a much more mercenary sociosexual landscape-there’s even a term for it-”Combat Dating”, or the even more simpler “Hooking Up”; and it means lonely, atomized people, Women and Men alike, “Bowling Alone”, to borrow Putnam’s famed book title.
Clearly, what Women across the age spectrum long for, per the Twilight business, is to be seduced, to be wanted, by a clearly superior Man. Yet the current times in which we live doesn’t support the creation, or maintenence, of such Men-you can thank the Four Sirens for that. Moreover, it takes A LOT of hard work for Man to successfully seduce a Woman, because in order to do so he has to take considerable time to learn to see the world as Women do and then take the time to work on himself into the kind of Man Women want, and then to perfect his skills in the field, through a good degree of trial and error-and that’s only the beginning. To keep said romance going over a longer period of time, requires the Man to constantly be on his toes. No wonder so few Men learn, or want to learn, Game.
So in that regard, it’s a Buyer’s Market for the relatively few Men out there, who have the Skills that pay the Bills-they can literally write their own ticket.
On the Male side, not only is it easier than ever “Not To Be”, but it threatens a kind of social atrophy that, left to its own devices and taken to extremes, can prove troublesome-even deadly. The Unabomber, George Sodini, and Muhammad Atta, are clear examples of this.
I wish I could end this essay on a more positive note; but I’m afraid I know Human Nature a bit too well for my own good. What’s more likely to happen over the course of the next decade is that we’ll see more Twilights and CODs, more disaffection and loneliness, more bitterness and recrimination between the Sexes, as the new configuration of the Sexual Marketplace begins to once again take shape in the next decade.
Hmm.
The Obsidian
The Obsidian